All cha-chings considered
We seem to have hit a nerve with yesterday's post about the top salaries at Tri-Met: more than a quarter million a year for the main man, 10 drawing more than $150,000 in annual salaries, and 20 over $125,000.
In addition to several comments about the Tri-Met salaries, we also got an e-mail message from a reader who thought we might like to take a similar look at what folks are making over at Oregon Public Broadcasting. The reader sent along a copy of OPB's annual disclosure form to the IRS, a public document that lists some of the big-money employees for the fiscal year that ended June 30, 2008. (We get the distinct impression that this reader has a grudge against the management over there, but hey, whatever his or her motive, the reader piqued our interest.)
It occurs to us that information like this merits a website all its own. Somewhere there ought to be a place where Portlanders can go to see the compensation levels of all the high-priced bureaucrats at public agencies and charities, at state and local levels. Something like an Orestar system, but for executive compensation. Does such a site exist? And if not, who out there is ready to lay a nice grant on us to get one started? Just a thought.
Anyhow, given the interest, we'll be following up with more salary information from various government agencies and nonprofits in the coming weeks, but what the heck -- here are the top eight individual execs from the OPB annual report:
Payee | Title | Compensation | Benefit plans and deferred comp. |
Steven Bass | President & CEO | $296,500 | $34,331 |
Dan Metziga | Senior VP - Development | $170,000 | $20,666 |
Maynard Orme | Former officer, director, trustee, or key employee | $159,810 | $14,383 |
Jan Heskiss | CFO & Asst. Secretary-Treasurer | $120,000 | $15,566 |
Dave Davis | VP - National Production | $117,500 | $15,341 |
Jeff Douglas | Senior VP - Station Manager | $117,000 | $15,296 |
Debbie Rotich | VP - HR & Admin. | $108,000 | $10,056 |
Tom Doggett | VP -TV Programming | $105,737 | $15,242 |
As best we can tell, Bass arrived in 2006 from Nashville, after Orme stepped down as president and CEO at age 68. But between just those two current and past top dogs, the organization paid $456,310 plus $48,714 in benis last year. How many days of pledge drive is that? Sheesh.
Anyway, not to pick on OPB in particular. We promise, we'll sniff around some other institutional payrolls in the weeks ahead and let you know what we find.
Comments (38)
Grant, schmant. I'll host it for free. E-mail me, we'll talk.
Posted by Steve R. | May 22, 2009 11:25 AM
Wow, I knew that Blumenauer's mass transit lobby in DC could garner enough stimulus and US taxpayer dollars to subsidize the bloated Tri-Met executive salaries. However, I did not know enough people watched OPB to justify that much compensation.
Do enough people watch OPB to justify the six figure salaries? Which legislators at the State and Federal level are responsible for funneling taxpayer dollars to OPB? Can we get some names?
Thanks. Great post.
Posted by YoungOregonMoonbat | May 22, 2009 11:34 AM
But between just those two current and past top dogs, the organization paid $456,310 plus $48,714 in benis last year. How many days of pledge drive is that? Sheesh.
What a poetic piece of synchronicity: that's just about what was claimed to have been collected in the Spring Begathon.
Posted by Allan L. | May 22, 2009 11:46 AM
Wow. Until those numbers come back down to earth I'm all done making donations. I had no idea.
Posted by ep | May 22, 2009 11:51 AM
The Oregonian put up a searchable database of local public employees earlier this year, I believe from 07-08 fiscal year (so almost a year old).
http://www.oregonlive.com/special/index.ssf/2009/01/query.html
Posted by Miles | May 22, 2009 12:03 PM
The Oregonian site is out of date -- no surprise -- and only includes public employees. I like Jack's idea of also documenting non-profit execs.
Posted by Steve R. | May 22, 2009 12:31 PM
And TRIMET just tossed the handsone LT Rail Bridge Design
and sent the Designer packing. Classy....
See more at Portland Spaces.com ,and Portland Architecture.com
Posted by billb | May 22, 2009 12:50 PM
I just realized why Tri-Met can't afford to fix the ticket machines.
Posted by Alan Cordle | May 22, 2009 12:55 PM
The OPB 990 has other fun facts, too. They paid around $230,000 to three fundraising contractors/consultants (which could be a bargain, for all I know); also, $168,454 to Speed's Supertow to haul around all those cars that people donate - that's a lotta clunkers!
Posted by Lalawethika | May 22, 2009 1:16 PM
I just got done cancelling my OPB membership.
Posted by RANZ | May 22, 2009 1:17 PM
Energy Trust?
PDC?
Goodwill?
Posted by ecohuman | May 22, 2009 1:20 PM
I think this may be one of the best posts you've ever run on the site, Jack, but I'll admit that I hold a grudge against OPB. A friend of my worked his way up from "Unpaid Intern" to "$9.00 an Hour Gopher" at OPB back in 2005. He was laid off right around Christmas that year because of "funding issues." This was supposed to be a career path for him and he wound up spending the following seven months wallowing in misery and unemployment. I wonder how much donor and taxpayer $ the President and CEO pulled in that calendar year.
What a repugnant organization. I'm disgusted. There's no reason, absolutely no reason, why anyone at OPB should be making a six-figure salary.
Posted by B | May 22, 2009 1:30 PM
To me, six figures is not, in and of itself, a big deal. Over a half-million for the current and retired CEOs is. You could also question the extra $50K for the development guy over the CFO. Stay tuned -- we'll have more.
Posted by Jack Bog | May 22, 2009 1:37 PM
The excuse they always use is that the pay is comparable to what their for-profit counterparts make, but I don't think they'd have any problems populating their ranks if they paid much less. They risk a huge public backlash with these salaries, because, as Jack says, how many days of pledges is that? I'd rather have OPB be funky and unpolished, than have them lay off $9/hour employees because to preserve the $300K salary of the top guy.
OPB is only the tip of the iceberg, of course. You'd find this type of compensation arrangement at most non-profits. People think non-profit means that the top guy makes $50K per year. That's why the worker bees at non-profits are fine making $20K. It's for the public good, after all. But most of the time, the top dogs make 10x what #2 or #3 in command make. The top dogs are fine keeping this hidden, even when the lower caste could find the information on the non-profit's publicly-available 990 forms.
If people saw the payroll of their favorite non-profits, there is a good chance they wouldn't want to work there or donate to them anymore.
Posted by James | May 22, 2009 2:05 PM
Jack - One candidate for investigation is the "Portland Family of Funds" and its affiliates. It's a strange "mutual benefit corporation" which receives New Market Tax Credits & dispenses taxpayer largesse on its favored chums. The board includes Carl Talton, Hank Ashforth and The Don Mazziotti - what's not to like? Extensive self-congratulatory websites claim creation of 8,000 jobs & $2.4 billion in econ activity, from projects like the Armory theater (in a 'low income' area!) and the infamous Vanport Square. They've got a staff of 15 or so, but list no salaries or financials. Mutual Benefit my eye... I'd like to know who put up the PFF capital, & where the profits go - I was once told they all go to "the Public," but it would be nice to see how - this of course means a big incentive for large salaries & bennies. (I took a class on Urban Renewal at PSU sponsored by the PDC & run by Carl Talton a few years back - He refused to allow questions that did not toe the Party Line, & anyone who did not toss softballs was not allowed to talk!) Maybe a good assignment for WW's Mr. Jaquiss?
Posted by Lalawethika | May 22, 2009 2:25 PM
In many public- and semipublic-funded operations, besides the salary spending we should see the advertising spending.
Do you really need the Post Office to advertise to you where you can buy stamps? At the monopoly?
When you really aspire to join the Army/Navy/Air Force/Marines/Coast Guard, or "the Guards," do you really need a billion (of your own taxes) dollars (each!) being spent to tell you where you go to buy in on the deal (singular) that is offered?
Oh, is advertising supposed to tell you price-comparison information so you can shop for the "better deal" than the monopoly offers?
Do you have a shopper's 'choice' of where to take your business when you're going to ride 'a' bus?
Do you shop for the cheaper electric power seller at your house?
Do you shop for the cheaper natural gas seller at your house?
Have you compared prices for which laws and which cops you prefer, in case you don't want to buy the packaged "click it or ticket" deal?
And -- my pointy-est dagger -- when you are going to give your extra money to Oregon 'economic development' (with the slim slim slim chance you'll get a BIG REBATE if you scratch off a winning 'receipt'), do you need a chunk of your change to be chisled off into a million$-dollar$ advertising splash that tells you there is only one Oregon lottery (monopoly) you can put your money in, and at the same time pours that ad money into paying for LIARS broadcast programming intending to incite weak-minded hysteria-impressioned raging apes to sabotage the public good and run subversive riot ruining community?
- -
But why don't we pay enough extra taxes for the local schools to advertise their 'features' we can't get anywhere else?
When (Oregon) Public Broadcasting is funded only by taxes, (NO pledge drives, NO corporate 'taglines'), then everyone is going to be paying beaucoup attention to the salaries at the station.
Posted by Tenskwatawa | May 22, 2009 2:28 PM
"The Oregonian site is out of date -- no surprise"
Hey it works for TorridJoe's salary. Now I can sleep much better. We should do an average pay for Randy's hey-boys vs the rest of the commissioners.
Posted by Steve | May 22, 2009 3:05 PM
Re those OPB salaries....not bad, considering they produce just three weekly locally-aired programs (Art Beat, Field Guide, and Oregon Experience). And if you ask them why they don't do more public affairs stuff like most PBS stations do, the answer always is that it costs too much. As one former employee said, "you could put up a satellite dish in the parking lot to air national programs, and OPB wouldn't look all that different." I suspect management salaries have increased over the last number of years during which time the state has eliminated funding and control over OPB.
Posted by Chuckmeister | May 22, 2009 3:11 PM
Hey it works for TorridJoe's salary.
How can he live in Lake O on that pittance?
Posted by Steve R. | May 22, 2009 3:19 PM
I'll never give another friggin dime to OPB, until they bring the Exec salaries in check.
Have you looked at the Goodwill salaries lately? Saw those in the papers a few years back. Seemed really excessive for a "charitable organization". I shop at Goodwill, and they have really JACKED the prices in the face of the economic downturn. A lot more people are shopping there, out of necessity. They are really sticking it to the underclass, to stoke the lifestyles of their wealthy rulers. Makes me sick.
Posted by Bilbo | May 22, 2009 4:49 PM
Miles: The Oregonian put up a searchable database of local public employees earlier this year, I believe from 07-08 fiscal year (so almost a year old).
http://www.oregonlive.com/special/index.ssf/2009/01/query.html
JK:I entered planner and got 357 hits!
This area has 357 government planners!
No wonder were so screwed up!
Thanks
JK
Posted by jim karlock | May 22, 2009 4:52 PM
How about the Port of Portland? Managers retire and collect their PERS retirement. Then come back working for the Port as a consultant. We should check to see how many are double dipping.
Posted by Mike | May 22, 2009 5:47 PM
Tensk, don't get me started on PGE's advertising. They have been paying Gerber Advertising (now Gard Gerber) for decades to promote them. PGE is probably GG's largest, longstanding account. A monopoly utility! PGE is constantly airing ads (TV & print), mailing flyers and sponsoring events, floats, etc. I'd rather they didn't do that and kept our electric rates lower.
The really galling hit was when they used money taken from the public to pay Gard Gerber to fight the idea of a PUD while dolling out hundreds of thousands in salaries and benefits to Peggy and her upper level cadre.
I worked for Gerber years ago during the summer and grew to loathe the sight of the Watt Watcher.
Posted by NW Portlander | May 22, 2009 6:12 PM
The OPB fundraising strategy isn't all that different from the televangelists, except OPB is producing a more tangible product than eternal salvation.
And they own the channel.
Posted by Mister Tee | May 22, 2009 6:45 PM
Want to get really scared? The next time you fly just realize the person landing the plane with hundreds if not thousands of hours of training is making less than a tri-met bus driver in most cases. I guess that union isn't strong enough
Posted by ace | May 22, 2009 7:34 PM
"LIARS broadcast programming intending to incite weak-minded hysteria-impressioned raging apes to sabotage the public good and run subversive riot ruining community?"
Tensky - Take a pill & calm down. Your nemesis Lars is ten times more civil on his worst days than your little alliterative run-on diatribes. A deep breath...
Posted by Lalawethika | May 22, 2009 8:25 PM
Re those OPB salaries....not bad, considering they produce just three weekly locally-aired programs (Art Beat, Field Guide, and Oregon Experience)
Er...they run a radio station too, you know.
Posted by Dave J. | May 22, 2009 8:47 PM
Jack-
As you may know, you can check out salaries for nonprofit executives online at www.guidestar.org. Unfortunately, it can take a few years for the 990s to post, but it can give you a feel for how much nonprofits pay their executive staff members.
-Charles
Posted by Charles | May 22, 2009 9:13 PM
Interesting contrast:
Two paid officers of PETA. Ingrid Newkirk's salary is $32,000; the v-p Marybeth Sweetland receives $68,500. Both work full-time.
Posted by Don | May 23, 2009 7:22 AM
Tensky,
"LIARS broadcast programming intending to incite weak-minded hysteria-impressioned raging apes to sabotage the public good and run subversive riot ruining community?"
What are you talking about?
Putting the partisan politics and Bush/Cheney hating aside, Lars' and his
audience have been accurate opponents of most of the local politicians and issues criticized by regular progressives here.
He's in aagreement and thorough about it.
It's the PDC et al who are sabotaging the public good.
Your yet to be determined affliction is causing you to cough up an endless stream of Lars hating phlegm unfit for any use.
Posted by Ben | May 23, 2009 8:46 AM
I guess I can stop feeling guilty now about watching and listening to OPB but not being a member anymore. That seems to be the gist of their fundraisers, that you're taking something without paying for it if you're not a member. Ugh! Thanks for letting us know who's doing the taking.
Posted by A Hopeful | May 23, 2009 9:14 AM
If this story has legs, we'll see some interesting items. For Portland Business Alliance: base salary only.
sandra mcdonough president & ceO 217,620
pamela knowles coo & general counsel 144,310
michael kuykendall vp of downtown services 125,469
Also, the executive secretary of the NW Oregon Labor Council (she's apparently the only paid officer) get $62.500.
Posted by Don | May 23, 2009 11:08 AM
"Putting the partisan politics and Bush/Cheney hating aside, Lars' and his
audience have been accurate opponents of most of the local politicians and issues criticized by regular progressives here."
Am mostly with you there, Ben.
Besides this wonderful blog, Lars is about the only local media voice that regularly points out the shenanigans, excesses going on at City Hall, in our public and quasi-public sectors.
Look at what else is out there:
OPB?-you must be kidding-they sup from the same trough.
WW?-sometimes
KABOO?- KABOO?…..Hello?……Hello?…..Anyone there?……..
The Big O?-you usually read about it first somewhere else
Local affiliates of the major TV Networks? rarely
On the Web-Blue Oregon: naw-it’s got much more important things to concern itself with
Granted Lars is a free market ideologue, a hater of "big government", a shill for corporate interests, who bullies, cuts off anyone who disagrees w/him-he can be very irritating.
Posted by Geoff | May 23, 2009 5:43 PM
Granted Lars is a free market ideologue, a hater of "big government", a shill for corporate interests, who bullies, cuts off anyone who disagrees w/him-he can be very irritating.
Oooh, let's add the right not to be irritated to the litany of "rights" added without a constitutional amendment by our legislative, oops, judicial branch.
It's soooo confusing; this separation of powers business...
...at least to moi.
For my part, I must now eschew listening to KMHD owing to heir affiliation with the government/media mob that is OPB.
I hope the blues survive this latest assault.
Posted by cc | May 23, 2009 6:27 PM
Hey, I know...
We can pay everyone, from the lowest ditch digger to the most esteemed law professor, $45,000 per year with free universal health coverage. Yay, equitable pay for equitable work!
Posted by Jupe Blue | May 24, 2009 8:15 AM
Geoff, you have to give credit to KATU for running some investigative reporting lately, even for tv. Let's commend those you are at least trying. We need more of it to fulfill Obama's Change-well some of it.
Posted by lw | May 24, 2009 7:50 PM
"Your yet to be determined affliction is causing you to cough up an endless stream of Lars hating phlegm unfit for any use.
Posted by Ben | May 23, 2009 8:46 AM "
===============
I think this is the funniest line I have ever read on this blog!!!
But I guess I did not know that there was any use of phlegm, regardless of if that phlegm was "Lars hating phlegm" or just garden variety phlegm.
Posted by Harry | May 24, 2009 9:56 PM
Returning to the specific subject of this thread, perhaps Mr Bass, a B-School grad, should return this week to the Western Ave campus to partake of the ethical influence of the current crop of graduates:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/30/business/30oath.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=Harvard%20Business%20School&st=Search
Perhaps a few other local non-profit CEOs might also partake of the New Idealism for the benefit of all of us.
Posted by Gardiner Menefree | May 31, 2009 12:55 PM